Pages
▼
Sunday, December 23, 2012
English innocence in Weimar Germany (Books - The Temple by Stephen Spender)
Oxford poets, Weimar Germany, you'd think that I would have enjoyed Stephen Spender's The Temple a little more. Spender wrote it in 1929-1930 at the age of 21, so it has all of the enthusiasm of that tender age. It was never published, I suppose, because it would have outed a few too many of his acquaintances and he feared action for libel. Spender rewrote it in 1986, updating it with clunky self-conscious awareness of the impending war that deprives the narrator of what I suspect was too embarrassing a show of political naivete. To my reading, this stripped what is already a work of patent juvenilia of most of its charm. What remains pscyhologically astute and historically interesting is the certainty of the young characters that Germany was in a revolutionary time of enlightened openness, that there would never be another war, and among the most educated of the characters, many of whom were Jewish or homosexual, a conspicuous blindness to the threat of the rising Nazi party. That observation and a good deal of decent descriptive writing kept me going.
I wonder how much of the political niavete comes from being 21. Younger people would have a much different take, often a more apolitical one, than others. I think young people are either very political or not political at all.
ReplyDeleteThat's an interesting question, CB. I think you're right in that many Germans old and young were naive regarding what was to come in 1930. Usually I like retrospective perspective, as Spender offers here, but as I read the book I kept wishing that he hadn't added his hindsight.
ReplyDeleteI just re-read this recently and kind of felt the same thing about the hindsight aspect you mention. I didn't notice any of this when I first read in 1989 when I was a naive 20 year old travelling in the UK for the first time.
ReplyDeleteThomas, that's right! I learned about this from you - I'm terrible about remembering these things. You were 1st reading the book around the same age he wrote it - I wonder if our more 'mature' pov simply makes us better readers or whether we have less in common with the way he experiences the story's events.
ReplyDeleteI Hope your christmas was happy. We're in ohio now and are expecting a blizzard today.